Now there are those who are gifted. My sister Karen loves music and would like to have been a singer really bad, but she is tone deaf and has no timing or rhythm. She could practice her entire life and never get any good at singing or playing the piano. She took organ lessons for two years and after all her lessons she sounded the same playing a tune as she did after one week. No progress at all. Its unbelievable.
I can certainly identify with that.
I did the same thing with the piano. I learned quite a bit and progressed quite a bit in the early going. Naturally I was starting from scratch so there was a lot of room for improvement in the early going.
However, I got to a brick wall that I could never get past.
For the next two years all I did was enlarge my repertoire of very poorly played pieces. I kept plugging along figuring that at some point I would 'break free' and start playing well, and then my entire repetoire would instantly improve in quality.
Unfortunately that never happened. I started to realize that even after two years I was no better than I was after the first month of playing. All I had done was added more poorly-played pieces to my list.
And I tired every trick in the book to improve my playing. I finally just concluded that my hands are never going to do what I want them to do.
I mean, I could already 'feel' the limitation in my hands. I knew precisely how I wanted simple phrases to sound, but I was unable to make my hand play them the way I wanted them to sound. So it was clearly a physical limitation. For some reason I just can't control my fingers to the degree than is necessary to make the music flow the way I want it.
I finally had to confess that I can't play the piano.
Here's a short excerpt of me playing Debussy's Clair de Lune.
http://www.csonline.net/designer/ideas/clair.htm
I did manage to get this down pretty well, the only problem is that I couldn't learn the next section at all. It was just way beyond my ability to play even remotely close to how it's supposed to sound. And that was after two years of practicing it!
I had no choice but to give up.
My hands just won't do it. They just don't work well enough. It's like there's a motor dysfunction or something when I reach a certain point of complexity and speed.