I guess I'm pretty lucky then.
My girlfriend's a pagan who doesn't smoke, doesn't drink, doesn't want children, and has animals instead. Plus she's extremely attractive, sexy, young, and doesn't mind if I worship her, the Mood Goddess, and talk to Faeries.
She also thinks that sex is spiritual and she's interested in having tantra sex whilst listening to nature music as well as practicing Boobism, er, I mean Buddhism.
She's extremely intelligent, well-educated, knows quite a bit about medicine and natural herbal cures.
I suppose I shouldn't be surprised that I found her though since I must confess that I asked the Goddess of Love to introduce us. So it wasn't an accident that we met.
In short, you don't need a pagan dating site. All you need to do is get on the good side of the Love Goddess.