Topic: *Ingsoc□Doublethink●Newspeak☆
Reply
no photo

The Wrong Alice

Thu 04/02/20 01:49 PM

All terms from the novel 1984 by George Orwell

Do you see them often, in your life and around you?

Do you believe we have freedom, or an Orwellian dystopia?

:see_no_evil::hear_no_evil::speak_no_evil:🧠:eyes:::🧜‍♂️🦚:rainbow:⚡🕉
Edited by The Wrong Alice on Thu 04/02/20 01:51 PM
Tom4Uhere's photo

Tom4Uhere

Thu 04/02/20 02:07 PM

Freedom, in a society, is an illusion/delusion.

The only real freedom you have is in your mind and that must be kept secret from society.

There is always a hierarchy in society. Always a ruling cast. Freedom equality can't exist in a society.

For those who think they are free, stop paying taxes, stop working, stop following the 'rules'.
Try building something on your so called "own" property without permit.
Try teaching your children outside sanctioned education imperatives.
Walk thru town with a gun.
Sit on your porch naked on a hot day, in the city.
Have sex where and when you want.
Take someone's stuff that has more than they need.
Drive an unregistered car on the public roads without a valid license.
Drive a car without insurance.

And the list goes on and on.

Orwell did not invent civil dystopia, he merely pointed out what society is and will be.
Ladywind7's photo

Ladywind7

Thu 04/02/20 02:36 PM

I think Orwell was encouraging us to think what we are thinking and to guard our language and what we are hearing.

Doublespeak? Politicians have used it always, nothing new there.




no photo

The Wrong Alice

Thu 04/02/20 11:18 PM

What if you are unable to keep a secret in your mind?
Perhaps you can do this consciously
But can you do it subconsciously and unconsciously?
And how can you be sure you can do that?
And if you cannot do that, or be sure that you can do that, then how can you keep a secret in your own mind

Thought police
Tom4Uhere's photo

Tom4Uhere

Thu 04/02/20 11:53 PM

A person who doesn't write and doesn't speak keeps the secret.
Communication is a choice.
Ladywind7's photo

Ladywind7

Fri 04/03/20 01:51 AM


What if you are unable to keep a secret in your mind?
Perhaps you can do this consciously
But can you do it subconsciously and unconsciously?
And how can you be sure you can do that?
And if you cannot do that, or be sure that you can do that, then how can you keep a secret in your own mind

Thought police


I would Triplethink it :smile:
Seriously, I would not cope in an Orwellian society. I would have been in the Ministry of Love a long time ago and tortured. I guess they can break your spirit, your mind and any freewill you may have....but is that living?
I honestly would be a revolutionist, or dead.
Such a cool topic R2D2....
no photo

The Wrong Alice

Fri 04/03/20 02:06 AM

How is subconscious or unconscious communication a choice?
A choice involves free will
If your free will is subverted , thus rendering you to act against your will and conscious mind, then how do you keep the secret in your mind?
If they could get the secret out of you when you were conscious, and you gave it willingly, then what need would they have to subvert the 2
no photo

The Wrong Alice

Fri 04/03/20 03:49 AM

Have you seen the film Slumdog millionaire Tom ( that's 1 example, I could cite others )
I mean you could interpret that film in a few different ways I suppose, but 1 interpretation that is frankly undeniable is this

The whole way through the film, the police use various techniques and methods to get the chap to tell them how he knew the answers to the questions, as they assume he's cheated
However at no point does he lie , or try to lie, abs he did not cheat
So, he did not try to keep a secret
But, could he have kept 1 if he wanted to ?