Topic: Billy Joel or Elton John
Reply
ivegotthegirth's photo

ivegotthegirth

Tue 03/02/21 05:49 PM

My favorite Billy Joel song======================

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6yYchgX1fMw
Tom4Uhere's photo

Tom4Uhere

Wed 03/03/21 11:13 AM

Oh yeah, I've heard him. (Glass Houses)
Sends me back to Loverboy days.
Reminds me of music the cheerleaders listened to.
Not really the kind of music I normally listen to.
Not really hearing a lot of keyboard/piano focus.
Its more of a yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah fake smile music to me.
I'll stick with Elton John.

I like
Piano Blues, Piano Blues Solo and Piano Blues Music with Piano Blues Licks & Improvisation
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uqA4UPiOjj0

I Like
Jazz Piano Hits & Soft Ballads
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=prtmoOfk28w

I Like
Piano Bar, Ragtime, ***** Tonk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mqfar2icF7o

I like
Piano Rock Ballads
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yU98ikucNQk

I Like
Piano Trance
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UqqDHySSneg

I Like
Relaxing Piano Music
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lCOF9LN_Zxs

But... I DON'T like Billy Joel's music.
no photo

Unknow

Wed 03/03/21 11:16 AM

The Stranger will always be my favorite Billy Joel album. A lot of his early stuff was personal to us here on Long Island. The Stranger was when we all said, wow, this guy is a breakout superstar.
Tom4Uhere's photo

Tom4Uhere

Wed 03/03/21 11:47 AM

Billy Joel - The Stranger
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E5ofVsxTPoc

Billy Joel - Piano Man (I've heard this before but didn't know the artist)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QwVjTlTdIDQ

Billy Joel - Scenes from an Italian Restaurant
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hxx8IWIvKg0&list=PLraUXdMOSKKFGJHUKaZnsswkOMFrwHsE5&index=4

Now, I like that a bit more.
Thanx
:thumbsup:
no photo

Unknow

Wed 03/03/21 12:41 PM

John Elton.
no photo

catinidaho

Wed 03/03/21 09:45 PM

i read the book Sex, Drugs and Cocoa Puffs. In chapter 4: How can I agree so much and disagree so much, at the same time.
no photo

catinidaho

Wed 03/03/21 10:34 PM

There are people who don't know Billy Joel? He held the title for a male with the most hit songs on the charts. Garth Brooks passed that, and he did that recording a Billy Joel song.
Tom4Uhere's photo

Tom4Uhere

Thu 03/04/21 08:56 AM

I haven't paid attention to music 'charts' since I turned 9.
As a teen I listened to hard rock "Disco Destroyer" channels and when I was working I listened to the blues on community radio.
Now I don't listen to radio at all.

Much of my youth was heavy metal/hard rock played very loud.

Some of the Billy Joel songs I have heard but didn't like enough to even try to find out who it was.
Now older, I have a 'listening ear' and tune to the instruments mostly. To me, the words of a song are less important unless they align with the instrument sounds.

Top or trending music seldomly appeals to me. Hip/Hop strikes me as shallow but I like a lot of Soul. I like Motown 60s and early 70s music. I can tolerate 50's music but its not a preference.

A lot of Billy Joel music reminds me of teeny bopper music. Its no wonder I can't associate the name. Elton John music mainly reminds me of adult music by comparison. But, I don't like a lot of Elton John songs either.

For the last 20 years or more, I've been listening to what I call 'selective music". Meaning I listen to the music I want to hear when I want to hear it.

According to other people I've met, I have great taste in music. I even get asked by strangers who is the band that's playing when I am in my truck. Mt gf listened to radio hits when I met her but has gotten a bunch of different music from me she never heard but really likes.

Like I said earlier, I like a few Billy Joel songs now (thanx geezer). I'm not set in stone about music.
Rap is not music so it doesn't count at all.
Rap makes me angry and I find it hostile and irritating.
I can't tolerate opera either but I like some opera metal.
I don't like much death metal anymore either.
My tastes have moved to easier listening and mellower music but I still rock out every once in a while.
Classical music I often find boring but tolerable.
I prefer instrumentals over vocals most of the time.
I like psy-goa trance and ambient trance for trance music. I can tolerate some dance trance but it gets old fast for me.
I prefer long songs over short ones.
I prefer mix selections over albums.
I like most any instrument played with mastery.
I remember the instrumental solo parts of songs before I learn the words to a song.
I set my sound system to less bass and higher treble.
I like music loud so it hits my body.
I can dance to nearly any tune.
I dream music in surround.
I can 'dance' without music, using memory and stay in rhythm.
In my youth I played acoustic guitar and drums.
I can create a tune on a keyboard.
I've had no musical lessons, ever.

Music has been part of my life since before I was born. My dad had a huge record collection and I have a huge mp3 collection. My dad organised and detailed his collection and I organise and detail mine.
Music is a bigger part of me than movies and I have a lot of movies.

So yes, I am not familiar with Billy Joel but most people are not familiar with most of the music I like.
I'm an oddball and proud of it.
no photo

Audi

Sat 04/17/21 02:16 PM

Elton is great, but Billy Joel is da' man.
no photo

Audi

Sat 04/17/21 02:19 PM


John Elton.

Based on your comment, I think you'll love this -- it's hilarious:

Rowan Atkinson - Interview with Elton John
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nl0HqlbX7dc
Jerry's photo

Jerry

Sat 07/10/21 09:23 PM

billy joel
no photo

catinidaho

Sat 07/10/21 09:47 PM

This has been interesting. Is it kind of equal Elton John and Billy Joel? I will always be Joel. I'm always liking his melodies and lyrics and singing.
no photo

Emily

Wed 07/14/21 08:03 AM

C'mon y'all its Elton john all the way
Slim gym 's photo

Slim gym

Wed 07/14/21 08:26 AM


I saw Billy Joel Live in about 1988. I was great.


we know you are!! but how about Billy ???
ha ha !!!
ivegotthegirth's photo

ivegotthegirth

Wed 07/14/21 09:55 AM

BILLY JOEL!!!
maybwecan's photo

maybwecan

Wed 07/14/21 03:12 PM

These questions always stir very incredible memories...sigh...my plate is a wee bit larger with room for Phil Collins and Eric Clapton...some days my frontrunner maybe influenced by a wonderful recent glass of port or reisling...laugh drinker
Edited by maybwecan on Wed 07/14/21 03:50 PM
Rock's photo

Rock

Thu 07/22/21 01:04 PM

I've never really cared for Elton John's style.
Seriously, Linus from The Peanuts, was a better
pianist.

Billy Joel was okay, right up to Nylon Curtain.

My biggest question about Joel's entire music catalog...
Is, why, for a song called 'Piano Man'...
Why does the guy with the harmonica never shut up?
I mean, the song isn't called 'Harmonica Man'.
Edited by Rock on Thu 07/22/21 01:14 PM
no photo

Unknow

Mon 07/26/21 05:22 PM

Wrong post sorry.
Edited by Unknow on Mon 07/26/21 06:08 PM
no photo

catinidaho

Mon 07/26/21 05:26 PM

Huh?
no photo

catinidaho

Mon 07/26/21 07:35 PM

I have about 50 songs to add, if anyone cared to know.